3 Empowerment Ranges in Product Administration


Being empowered could make all of the distinction in doing an ideal job. Sadly, not all product folks have the authority they want. This statement is hardly new, although, and simply wishing for extra empowerment is not sufficient. On this article, I clarify what empowerment in product administration actually means. I provide help to decide how empowered you’re, and I share particular tricks to enhance your empowerment.

Hearken to the audio model of this text:


To debate empowerment in product administration, I discover it useful to differentiate three most important ranges of decision-making authority, product supply, product discovery, and product technique, because the mannequin in Determine 1 reveals.[1]

3 Empowerment Levels in Product Management
Determine 1: An Empowerment Mannequin for Product Individuals and Groups

Stage one represents the authority to determine how options are detailed and information their implementation. Stage two will increase empowerment by including the authority to find out the options and consumer expertise the product ought to provide. Stage three, lastly, permits product folks and groups to develop the product technique together with the worth proposition and enterprise targets.

Earlier than I focus on the three ranges in additional element, let me briefly clarify why I wrote this text. My intention is that will help you higher perceive your present degree of empowerment, determine whether it is applicable, and decide the way you may strengthen your authority. Should you handle a gaggle of product folks, for instance, as the top of product, I hope that the article will provide help to decide if the group’s empowerment is ample.

I definitely don’t intend to make anybody really feel unhealthy. On the similar time, I consider that you will need to have a look at issues the best way they’re. It’s step one to result in constructive change.

Stage 1: Product Supply

In case your job is to determine how options are applied and when you work with one or two growth groups to ship them, then you’re at degree one. Listed here are 4 indicators that that is the case:

  • Stakeholders, administration, or one other, extra strategic product function decide which options should be offered and talk them to you, for instance, throughout a dash evaluation assembly or within the type of characteristic requests.[2]
  • The product backlog, or one in every of its subsets, and the launch plan are the primary artefacts you’re employed with.
  • You spend a big quantity of your time refining product backlog objects, writing consumer tales, monitoring the event progress, and speaking to growth crew members.
  • You aren’t ready to say no characteristic requests.

Whereas the work you do at degree one is efficacious, your function is much like a venture or supply supervisor. As you aren’t empowered to find out the product options, you aren’t ready to handle the product and considerably affect the worth it creates. To place it in a different way, level-one empowerment is not ample for being an efficient product supervisor or Scrum product proprietor.[3]

Stage 2: Product Discovery

Stage-two empowerment implies that you establish the product options and consumer expertise. You might be often at this degree if the next 5 standards apply:

  • You perform product discovery actions together with speaking to customers, detailing consumer wants, and deriving the suitable product options.
  • You utilize an outcome-based product roadmap and/or an alternative resolution tree, personas, consumer journey maps, and the product backlog to seize and validate your choices and information the product supply effort.
  • You handle the stakeholders, for instance, by inviting them to roadmapping workshops and dash evaluation conferences or by having common one-on-ones with them.
  • You’re employed in direction of an overarching product technique, which states the worth the product ought to create for the customers, prospects, and enterprise. The technique could also be developed by the top of product or one other senior supervisor.
  • You might be empowered to decline a characteristic request if it doesn’t meet the agreed strategic aims.

At degree two, you’ll be able to really handle the product and affect the worth it creates. Consequently, that is the minimal degree of empowerment product managers and Scrum product homeowners in addition to product groups require.[4]

Stage 3: Product Technique

In case you are authorised to find out not solely the product options but in addition the product technique, you expertise level-three empowerment. Listed here are three indicators that you’re at this degree:

Should you’re at this degree, you have got full-stack empowerment: You might be authorised to make strategic choices along with solution-focused ones. I usually suggest that product folks and product groups have level-three empowerment. This permits them to innovate quick and maximise worth creation.

In case you are conversant in my work, this suggestion gained’t be a shock. I’ve advocated level-three empowerment for product managers and Scrum product homeowners for a few years. For instance, I write in my guide Strategize: “Because the individual answerable for the product, you ought to personal the product technique (…), and you have to be empowered to have the ultimate say on strategic choices.”[5]

It’s not unusual, although, that the top of product—additionally known as Director of Product Administration, VP of Product, and Chief Product Officer—determines the product technique. Sadly, this could trigger the top to be overworked, turn out to be a bottleneck, and decelerate decision-making. Proactively growing the product technique and finishing up steady strategizing work requires a big effort. Moreover, it prevents the contributors from including as a lot worth as attainable, and it will possibly result in decrease morale and productiveness.

As an alternative of making and evolving the methods of particular person merchandise, the top of product ought to assist the contributors make the suitable strategic choices, for instance, by mentoring and training them or by asking them to attend my technique and roadmap coaching. Moreover, the person ought to make sure that the general product portfolio is successfully managed, as I clarify in additional element within the article Ought to a Head of Product Make Strategic Product Selections.

Levelling Up

It’s all good and effectively to grasp your present degree of empowerment. However how will you enhance your empowerment and transfer up from degree one to ranges two and three? The transient reply is: By rising your referent and skilled energy and by bringing about some organisational change, as Determine 2 reveals.

Empowerment Factors
Determine 2: Empowerment Components

Referent and skilled energy seek advice from your potential to affect others together with administration, stakeholders, and growth groups.[6] The previous relies on the respect and belief folks have in you; the latter is based in your experience. The extra folks belief you and the extra educated you’re, the extra they are going to hearken to your recommendation and allow you to decide the product options and make strategic product choices. It’s subsequently fascinating to develop each powers.

Growing Your Referent and Skilled Energy

A good way to develop your referent energy is to empathise with folks, practise energetic listening, communicate and act with integrity, be accountable, and contain folks in product choices, as I clarify in additional element within the video beneath.

To strengthen your skilled energy, purchase the required product administration expertise and the related information about your product and its market. For instance, growing your potential to grasp consumer wants, create an efficient product roadmap, decide the suitable product options, and prioritise the product backlog will provide help to step as much as degree two. Having the ability to do market and competitor analysis, carry out aggressive evaluation, create, validate, and evolve a product technique, perform enterprise modelling and give you a monetary forecast, in addition to use the suitable KPIs will allow you to maneuver as much as degree three.

Affecting Organisational Change

However as Determine 2 illustrates, rising skilled and referent energy will not be sufficient. Say that you end up at degree one. You might be then unlikely to attain level-two empowerment with out your function being adjusted and its authority and accountability being modified. These modifications will most definitely require the assist of your boss. If there’s a bigger affect, nonetheless, as an example, on profession paths, growth applications, and worker choice standards, then you’re prone to require the involvement of HR and the backing of senior administration.

To deliver in regards to the obligatory modifications, attempt to affect the decision-makers and assist them perceive why product folks require no less than level-two empowerment—ideally after you have got labored in your referent and skilled energy.[7] But when this fails, you’re confronted with two choices: settle for the established order or look elsewhere for a product administration job that provides the suitable degree of empowerment.


[1] The mannequin in Determine 1 takes benefit of the technique, discovery, and supply distinction described in Marty Cagan’s guide Impressed, 2nd ed. Word that the mannequin defines empowerment as having the required decision-making authority and having possession of the product or no less than some features of it.

[2] I take advantage of the time period characteristic to seek advice from a product functionality, for instance, commenting on this text.

[3] In an agile, Scrum-based course of, the venture administration work is collaboratively carried out by the Scrum product proprietor and the event crew with the latter taking up a lot of the work. Within the scaling framework SAFe, nonetheless, the SAFe product proprietor has level-one empowerment, so far as I can inform.

[4] Marty Cagan calls groups, which lack level-two empowerment, “characteristic groups”.

[5] I proceed by saying: “However this doesn’t imply that you must create the technique and roadmap by yourself, hand the completed plans to the stakeholders and growth groups, and anticipate them to place them into motion. Irrespective of how effectively thought-out your product technique and roadmap are, they’re nugatory if the stakeholders and growth groups don’t purchase into them. It’s best to subsequently contain them in creating and updating the plans, ideally within the type of collaborative workshops.” Strategize, 2nd ed., p. 20.

[6] Referent and skilled energy had been first described by French and Raven of their paper The Foundation of Social Energy. They’re additionally known as private energy to differentiate them from positional energy, which is derived from a place within the org chart. See additionally my article Decoding Product Management for extra info.

[7] If in case you have certified coaches in your organisation, ask them to assist you. A Scrum Grasp, for instance, is supposed to deal with organisational impediments and assist deliver in regards to the modifications obligatory to determine an efficient approach of working. This contains rising the empowerment of the product folks.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here