[Book Review] “Escape from Mannequin Land” by Erica Thompson


Supply:  Fundamental Books

Predictive mathematical fashions contact our lives nearly day-after-day. Each climate forecast we watch, hear, or learn is formulated primarily based on a number of atmospheric fashions. And that is only one instance.

Predictive fashions have additionally change into an integral a part of fashionable advertising and marketing. For instance, entrepreneurs use mathematical fashions to find out the optimum combine of promoting applications (advertising and marketing combine fashions), establish the attributes of their greatest prospects, and personalize advertising and marketing communications and different types of advertising and marketing content material.

The first operate of most mathematical fashions in advertising and marketing is to establish patterns in present knowledge after which apply these patterns to foretell the seemingly future outcomes or outcomes of promoting selections or applications.

The usage of predictive fashions in advertising and marketing is poised to extend considerably due to persevering with advances in synthetic intelligence. For those who want proof of this progress, simply have a look at the explosion of generative AI purposes because the public launch of OpenAI’s ChatGPT in November 2022.

All this makes it important that entrepreneurs have a fundamental understanding of how mathematical fashions are constructed, how they work, and why they do not all the time produce correct forecasts. This makes Escape from Mannequin Land:  How Mathematical Fashions Can Lead Us Astray and What We Can Do About It (Fundamental Books, 2022) a e-book all entrepreneurs ought to learn.

Escape from Mannequin Land was written by Erica Thompson, an affiliate professor at College School London (UCL) and a Fellow on the London Mathematical Laboratory. Beforehand, she was a senior coverage fellow on the Knowledge Science Institute at The London College of Economics and Political Science. Thompson holds a PhD in physics from Imperial School.

What’s Within the Guide

Escape from Mannequin Land accommodates ten chapters. Within the first six chapters, Thompson focuses on the attributes and limitations of mathematical fashions. She observes that individuals who design and construct fashions work in a beautiful place she dubs “Mannequin Land.” In Mannequin Land, she writes, all of the assumptions that underlie a mannequin are “actually true,” and all of the uncertainties are quantifiable.

The issue is that these situations do not exist in the true world. Thompson writes, “Deep or radical uncertainty enters the scene within the type of unquantifiable unknowns:  issues we disregarded of the calculation that we merely couldn’t have anticipated . . . In that case, your rigorously outlined statistical vary of projected outcomes would transform utterly insufficient.”

Escape from Mannequin Land discusses a number of different limitations of fashions. For instance, Thompson observes that each one fashions are oversimplifications of the true world, which suggests they supply an incomplete image of actuality. She writes, ” We would consider fashions as being caricatures . . . Inevitably, they emphasize the significance of sure sorts of options . . . and ignore others utterly.”

Thompson additionally factors out {that a} mannequin builder makes quite a few selections when growing a mannequin – what to place in, what to go away out, what scientific and mathematical strategy to take, and so on. Subsequently, a mannequin will replicate the values, training, and tradition of the mannequin builder, which implies that it solely presents one perspective of a given scenario when, actually, a number of views are attainable.

All through the e-book, Thompson exposes the restrictions and “blind spots” of predictive fashions, however she doesn’t argue they need to be relegated to the junk pile. Close to the top of Chapter 1, Thompson features a passage that describes the problem she hopes the e-book addresses. She writes:

“I’ve tried to discover a balanced strategy to proceed in between what I feel are two unacceptable options. Taking fashions actually and failing to account for the hole between Mannequin Land and the true world is a recipe for underestimating threat and struggling the results of hubris. But throwing fashions away utterly would lose us lots of clearly helpful data.”

Thompson makes use of the ultimate chapter of Escape from Mannequin Land to supply 5 ideas for addressing this problem.

  • Outline the Objective – “As a place to begin for creating fashions, we have to determine what objective(s) they’re alleged to be put . . . Most fashions are usually not sufficient for the aim of creating any determination, though they could be sufficient for the aim of informing the decision-maker about some elements of the choice.”
  • Do not Say “I Do not Know” – “If we can provide up on the prospect of excellent data and let go of the hope of probabilistic predictions . . . there are different narratives in every mannequin which in themselves comprise helpful insights . . . We all know nothing for sure, however we have no idea nothing.”
  • Make Worth Judgements – “All fashions require worth judgements . . . Once you perceive the worth judgements you might have made, write them down . . . Enable for representations of different judgements with out demonising these which might be completely different from your personal.”
  • Write Concerning the Actual World – “Once you’re explaining your outcomes to anyone else, get out of Mannequin Land and personal the outcomes . . . in what methods is that this mannequin insufficient or misinformative? What essential processes does it fail to seize?”
  • Use Many Fashions – “. . . gathering insights from as various a variety of views as attainable will assist us to be maximally knowledgeable concerning the prospects and prospects of the longer term.”

My Take

Escape from Mannequin Land is well-written, accessible, and fascinating. Erica Thompson does a wonderful job of creating the complicated, technical points of mathematical fashions straightforward for these of us who aren’t educated knowledge scientists to grasp.

This e-book shouldn’t be particularly about advertising and marketing, but it surely accommodates a message that’s essential and well timed for entrepreneurs. Over the previous a number of years, entrepreneurs have more and more relied on knowledge to tell their selections, and up to date advances in synthetic intelligence will seemingly enhance this reliance.

There isn’t any doubt that knowledge analytics and AI may help entrepreneurs make extra evidence-based selections, however these instruments even have limitations that always go unrecognized – or not less than underappreciated.

The obvious precision of numbers and the halo of scientific validity surrounding AI can simply create an phantasm of certainty that provides us a false sense of confidence within the outputs these instruments produce.

Escape from Mannequin Land reminds us that advertising and marketing ought to all the time be “data-informed,” however by no means completely “data-driven.” 


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here