[Research Round-Up] The Effectiveness of AI-Generated Photographs for Advertising and marketing


Supply:  Shutterstock

(This 12 months, I am devoting a few of my Analysis Spherical-Up posts to educational analysis papers referring to using synthetic intelligence for advertising functions. This put up options an unpublished paper that compares the efficiency of AI-generated vs. human-made pictures throughout three advertising use circumstances.)

The facility of generative advertising:  Can generative AI attain human-level visible advertising content material?

  • Authors – Jochen Hartmann and Yannick Exner, Technical College of Munich; Samuel Domdey, Technical College of Hamburg-Harburg
  • Date Written – July 12. 2023

This paper describes the outcomes of three research designed to judge the efficiency of AI-generated vs. human-made pictures used for advertising functions. Particularly, the research evaluated picture efficiency throughout three dimensions related to advertising.

  • Human notion of picture high quality and realism
  • Social media engagement
  • Click on-through charges of banner adverts

The research used AI-generated pictures created with 13 text-to-image diffusion fashions, together with DALL-E2, Jasper, Midjourney v4, and several other variations of Steady Diffusion. Altogether, these research collected greater than 17,000 human evaluations of over 1,500 AI-generated pictures.

All the AI-generated pictures in these research have been created utilizing a two-step course of. In step one, the researchers employed an image-to-text AI mannequin to create a textual description of every human-made comparability picture. These textual descriptions have been then used (with out modification) because the prompts to provide the AI-generated pictures.

Listed here are abbreviated descriptions of the three research and the high-level outcomes of every examine.

Examine 1 – Human Notion of High quality and Realism

The target of this examine was to match the perceived high quality and realism of AI-generated vs. human-made pictures throughout three advertising use circumstances – product design, social media, and print adverts. 

Every picture was rated by 5 human evaluators for high quality and realism utilizing a 7-point Likert scale (1 = low, 7 = excessive), leading to a complete of seven,830 rankings.

The rankings for high quality and realism different relying on the particular picture being evaluated and on the mannequin used to create the AI-generated picture. Total, nevertheless, the examine revealed that the AI-generated pictures outperformed or have been on par with the human-made pictures within the product design and social media use circumstances.

Within the print advert use case, the AI-generated pictures have been considerably much less more likely to carry out on par with the human-made pictures by way of perceived high quality and realism.

Once more, the rankings different considerably relying on the mannequin used to create the AI-generated picture. So, the selection of mannequin issues.

Examine 2 – Social Media Engagement

This examine’s goal was to match the flexibility of AI-generated pictures vs. a human-made picture to provide engagement in a social media setting. On this examine, engagement referred to the “chance to love” a picture and the “chance to remark” on a picture.

This examine included one human-made picture and 13 AI-generated pictures. The researchers recruited 701 members who have been randomly assigned to one of many 14 pictures. Every participant was requested to charge how possible they have been to love or touch upon a picture utilizing a 7-point Likert scale (1=low, 7=excessive).

The outcomes of this examine confirmed that the AI-generated pictures usually carried out on par with the human-made picture by way of social media engagement.

Examine 3 – Click on-By means of Charges On Banner Advertisements

The target of this examine was to match the effectiveness of AI-generated pictures vs. a human-made picture when utilized in a web based banner advert. The measure of effectiveness used was click-through charges (CTR).

This examine was a randomized area experiment that consisted of a real-world on-line banner advert marketing campaign run on a number one show promoting platform. The human-made picture was knowledgeable picture bought from Adobe Inventory. The marketing campaign ran December 28-29, 2022, and generated 702 clicks on 86,809 impressions.

Of the 14 pictures examined, the human-made picture ranked tenth by way of CTR. One of the best-performing AI-generated picture achieved a 21.5% increased CTR in comparison with the human-made picture.

This examine additionally demonstrated that mannequin alternative issues. One of the best-performing AI mannequin (Steady Diffusion v1-3) outperformed the worst mannequin (Disco Diffusion) by 65.5%.

My Take

The three research described within the Hartmann et al. paper display that generative AI fashions can create visible content material that’s on par with – and infrequently higher than – human-made pictures for quite a lot of advertising use circumstances.

If something, these research most likely underestimate the flexibility of generative AI fashions to provide human-level visible content material. The prompts used to create the AI pictures for these research have been produced by an image-to-text AI mannequin, and the researchers did not modify these prompts. Prompts engineered by skilled entrepreneurs would possible have resulted in more practical AI pictures.

These research additionally most likely underestimate the standard of pictures generative AI fashions can at the moment produce as a result of new, extra succesful variations of among the fashions used within the research have been launched because the research have been carried out. For instance, these research used DALL-E2 and Midjourney v4, however DALL-E3 and Midjourney v6 at the moment are accessible.

At minimal, the outcomes of those research recommend that AI-generated pictures are more likely to play an more and more necessary function in advertising.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here