Why a Seed VC Ought to Care Extra About Possession Than Valuation on Every New Funding, However Perceive the Fund Impression of Paying Too A lot Too Typically


My associates at Weekend Fund not too long ago put out a round-up e-newsletter of some investor responses to the query “Do Valuations Matter?” It’s all value studying however I’ll excerpt my ideas right here because it’s a dialogue Satya and I’ve usually with new VCs.

scales of justice statue with greenback payments on every scale, cartoon artwork

How Hunter Stroll @ Homebrew approaches valuations 

Homebrew is an evergreen fund investing primarily in pre-seed, seed and Sequence A rounds. 

Like NEA, Homebrew takes an ownership-driven method to investing. They view valuation as an essential guardrail in evaluating an funding alternative. Hunter additionally breaks down their framework for evaluating an funding alternative when attaining their goal possession exceeds their most test measurement, and the “alternative price” of doing so leading to much less diversification. 

Extra from Hunter: 

“In our traditionally concentrated method to seed stage investing, hitting our possession goal mattered greater than valuation *however* valuation was an extremely essential guardrail in evaluating a possibility, for it has nice influence on the corporate and our portfolio administration general. 

We set a ‘max test measurement’ for our preliminary investments which was meant to get us, on common, 10-15% possession and if held to, would general information us to an funding interval that supplied each time and firm diversification for the fund. It additionally drove our reserves technique. So in any negotiation, whether or not we wrote our ‘max test’ to get the goal possession was an element of spherical measurement, firm stage, and so forth. However we’d not often stroll away from a possibility primarily based on valuation if it matches inside that focus on possession and check-size field. 

In conditions the place concentrating on the 10-15% possession would have required a dedication bigger than our ‘max test measurement’ we needed to determine whether or not (a) the chance right here was value 1.5 or 2 slots – ie are we going to make one fewer funding out of the fund as a way to do that one or (b) would we follow our test measurement however take decrease possession in consequence or (c) stroll away. Of those three, (c) was the most typical determination for quite a lot of causes that had been about being constant in our technique and product providing.”
— Hunter Stroll (Homebrew) 

Examine your degree of conviction to the value the market is setting

“The ‘valuation query’ is one which comes up continuously in our discussions with the rising managers we again by way of Screendoor (the place we’ll make investments as much as 10% of a fund’s goal elevate and produce them right into a neighborhood of buyers ongoing for a lot of these questions). Whereas conditions can differ, my common rule is that the market determines the value, so you need to sort of determine whether or not your conviction in an organization is the same as, better, or lower than value the market is telling you they’re ‘value.’”

Be disciplined to make sure you can hit a minimal portfolio measurement 

“It’s an influence legislation enterprise so an EM desires to have the ability to present the standard of their entry, selecting, and successful. Having laborious and quick ceilings on what you’re keen to pay, or attempting to over concentrate on the higher sure of your possession goal too early in your enterprise lifecycle may make it harder to show choice success. So don’t routinely overpay or outbid, particularly once you don’t consider within the firm as a lot because the market does, however potential LPs will probably be extra within the variety of profitable investments you picked than your entry value in them. Simply preserve sufficient self-discipline to make sure you can hit a minimal portfolio measurement.”

Valuation negotiations can reveal lots 

“Moreover the maths of all of it, valuation negotiations can inform you a large number about what issues to the founders, the kind of relationship they wish to have with their buyers, and the objectives they should obtain to finish profitable subsequent financing.”


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here